By: Paolo Calchi Novati and Isabela Koebel
The current collective bargaining agreement between PUSD and the UTP outlines the procedure
for investigating and punishing district employees (including teachers) in Article XXIV,
“Discipline”. This procedure is a type of “progressive discipline,” in which the level of discipline
increases each time an employee repeats an offense.
While a district employee is being disciplined, the UTP is kept informed about the various steps
of discipline and is also able to provide the employee with legal representation.
The first step in the district’s method of progressive discipline is a verbal warning to the
employee, followed by a written warning and a written reprimand. If all of these measures fail,
the employee can be suspended for up to 15 days. Employees also cannot be dismissed through
the procedures in this article.
However, Section 1.3 of Article XXIV states three exceptions to the normal process and
penalties of this article: California Ed Code Sections 44939, 44940, and 44942.
Section 44939 covers what happens to employees that are charged with “immoral conduct,
conviction of a felony or of any crime involving moral turpitude, with incompetency due to
mental disability, with willful refusal to perform regular assignments without reasonable cause,
as prescribed by reasonable rules and regulations of the employing school district,” or with
violating Section 51530, which prevents public school teachers from indoctrinating children into
communism. District employees that violate Ed Code 44939 may be suspended and dismissed
unless they demand and win a hearing against the school district about their suspension.
Section 44940 lists a variety of offenses that may result in employees receiving a mandatory or
optional leave of absence. The offenses that can lead to a mandatory leave of absence include
various sex and controlled substances offenses, as well as murder and attempted murder. The
offenses that can result in an optional leave of absence include various other controlled substance
offenses that do not involve peyote, marijuana, mescaline, or tetrahydrocannabinols.
In addition to their suspension, employees who violate Section 44940 will also have their
teaching credential suspended, and may be fired by the district.
Section 44942 states that certificated district employees, which include teachers, may be
“suspended or transferred to other duties” if the school board finds that the employee has a
mental illness that makes them unable to conduct their duties. The employee then has the right to
appear before a panel and be examined by psychological experts. If the panel decides that the
employee is fit to work, they will be able to return to their job, and if not, the employee is placed
on mandatory sick leave. After various other hearings, the school board can either reinstate the
employee or dismiss them from their position.
But the teacher’s union provides access to pathways for due process, which will fairly and justly
evaluate a teacher’s position. Bethel Lira, the vice president and bargaining chairperson of the
teacher’s union and a teacher here at Marshall, argues on behalf of teachers.
“We don’t protect people who break the law. So what we protect is due process rights. If there is
an allegation of sexual misconduct, for example, the district has the right to place that person on
a paid administrative leave. So they’ll still continue to collect their salary and their health and
welfare benefits until the investigation is complete,” said Lira.
So, teachers who may have recently been put under investigation for sexual misconduct cannot
be fired unless they have done something against the law.
Permanency is another benefit the teacher’s union provides. Many confuse it with tenure, a
system that universities use, but in the PUSD school system, permanency works a bit differently.
“What protections you have when you’re permanent is you have those due process rights. So they
have to have cause in order to terminate your employment,” said Lira.
Permanency also leads into seniority, which protects teachers who have been here for longer
from layoffs and was a large part of the recent budget cuts.
